Broker selection

ECN vs market maker brokers

Brokers fill your orders in different ways. Some pass them to outside liquidity providers; others take the other side themselves. Both models are legal and common. What matters is how the broker manages the conflict and what it costs you.

Guide · 7 min read     Updated 3 Nov 2026     Reviewed by the research desk

The main models

Market maker (dealing desk). The broker quotes its own prices and is the counterparty to your trades. Spreads are often fixed or wider and commission-free.

STP (straight-through processing). Orders are passed to one or more liquidity providers, usually with a mark-up added to the spread.

ECN. Orders meet prices from several liquidity providers. Raw spreads are tight and the broker charges a commission per lot.

Many brokers mix models, keeping some client trades in-house and passing others on. Account names such as "ECN" or "Raw" describe pricing, not always how orders are routed.

Feature
Market maker
STP / ECN
Pricing
Broker sets the quote
From liquidity providers
Typical cost
Wider spread, no commission
Raw spread plus commission
Conflict of interest
Broker may profit when clients lose
Lower, but mark-ups and routing still matter
Requotes
Possible
Rare; slippage instead

What to check in the documents

Read the order execution policy and the conflicts of interest policy. Regulated brokers in the UK and EU must publish both. Look for how prices are formed, whether slippage can go in your favour as well as against you, and what the broker does in fast markets.

Questions to ask
✓Who is the counterparty to my trades on this account?
✓Is positive slippage passed on to clients?
✓What is the total cost per round turn on EUR/USD, including commission?
✓Are execution statistics published, and how recent are they?

Common mistakes

✕Assuming "ECN" in an account name means ECN execution. Ask how orders are routed.
✕Comparing spreads without commission. A 0.0-pip spread with a commission can cost more than a 0.8-pip spread without one.
Ready to compare the terms?
Put up to three brokers side by side: costs, platforms, leverage and award history.
Compare brokers
FA
Written by the Forex Awards research desk

Guides are checked against current broker documents and regulator rules. Spotted something out of date? Tell us and we will re-check it.

Keep learning

Guides readers open next.

All guides →
Guide · 7 min read
Spreads, commissions and the true cost of a trade

Compare account pricing on equivalent terms, not headline numbers.

Read guide →
Guide · 5 min read
How to check a broker's legal entity

Find the right documents and use an official regulator register.

Read guide →
Guide · 8 min read
MT4 vs MT5: which platform fits your trading?

Understand the tools, order types and questions to ask before choosing.

Read guide →